Home/Engage/Article

Oct 28, 2024 49 Father Joseph Gill, USA
Engage

Why am I not feeling closer to God when I pray?

Q I don’t feel God’s presence when I pray. Am I making any progress in the spiritual life if I don’t feel close to Him?

A If you struggle to feel God’s presence in your prayer life, you are in good company! Most of the great Saints went through a time of dryness. Mother Teresa, for example, went for thirty-five years without feeling His presence. Every day, for years, when Saint John of the Cross would record in his journal what spiritual insights or inspirations he received in prayer, he would write one word: “Nada” (“Nothing”). Saint Therese of Lisieux wrote this about her darkness: “My joy consists in being deprived of all joy here on earth. Jesus does not guide me openly; I neither see nor hear Him.”

Saint Ignatius of Loyola called this experience ‘desolation’—when we feel like God is distant, when our prayers feel hollow and that they are bouncing off the ceiling. We feel no delight in the spiritual life, and every spiritual activity feels like it’s a chore and a slog uphill. It is a common feeling in the spiritual life.

We must be clear that desolation is not the same as depression. Depression is a mental illness that affects every part of one’s life. Desolation specifically impacts the spiritual life—a person going through desolation still enjoys their life overall (and things might be going very well!) but is only struggling in the spiritual life. At times the two come together, and some people might experience desolation while experiencing other types of suffering, but they are distinct and not the same.

Why does desolation happen? Desolation can have one of two causes. Sometimes desolation is caused by unconfessed sin. If we have turned our back on God, and perhaps we are not acknowledging it, God may withdraw a sense of His presence as a means to draw us back to Him. When He is absent, we may thirst for Him more! But many times, desolation is not caused by sin, but is an invitation from God to pursue Him more purely. He takes away the spiritual candy, so that we seek Him alone and not just good feelings. It helps purify our love for God, so that we love Him for His own sake.

What do we do in a time of desolation? First, we ought to look into our own life to see if we do need to repent of any hidden sin. If not, then we must persevere in prayer, in sacrificing, and with our good resolutions! One should never give up praying, especially when it’s difficult. However, it might be helpful to diversify our prayer life—if we always pray the Rosary daily, maybe we should go to Adoration or read Scripture instead. I have found that a wide variety of different prayer practices can provide God many different avenues to speak and move in my life. 

But the good news is that faith is not feelings! Regardless of what we ‘feel’ in our relationship with God, it is more important to stand upon what He has revealed. Even if we feel He is distant, we remember His promise that “I am with you always, to the end of the age.” (Matthew 28:20) If we are struggling to motivate ourselves to pray or practice virtue, we stand on His promise that “no eye has seen, nor ear heard, nor the human heart conceived, what God has prepared for those who love Him.” (1 Corinthians 2:9) When we are struggling to find God’s presence because of sufferings that have befallen us, we remember His promise that “We know that all things work together for good for those who love God.” (Romans 8:28) Our faith must be grounded on something deeper than whether or not we feel His presence.

Conversely, feeling close to God is not always a guarantee that we are in His good graces. Just because we ‘feel’ that a choice is right does not make it correct if it goes against God’s law that He has revealed through the Scriptures and the Church. Our feelings are not the same as our faith!

Desolation is a struggle for every Saint and sinner as we continue through the spiritual life. The key to making progress is not feelings, but rather persevering in prayer through the deserts, until we come to the promised land of God’s abiding presence!

Share:

Father Joseph Gill

Father Joseph Gill is a high school chaplain and serves in parish ministry. He is a graduate from Franciscan University of Steubenville and Mount St. Mary’s Seminary. Father Gill has published several albums of Christian rock music (available on iTunes). His debut novel, “Days of Grace” is available on amazon.com.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest Articles